
How odd it feels to enter the hallowed halls of the Met on a Sunday, and yet how perfectly natural since, for some of us, this is church. Or in Gioconda's case, schul (We are of mixed heritage here at Trrill… or some of us are: half Jewish, half diva.)
Church in America, they say, is as much a social ritual as a religious one: see, be seen, hold forth with your opinions that everyone has already heard, and look riveted when others do the same. During the boring parts, it's perfectly okay to make mental lists of your favorite vegetables or people you're better than or whatever it is you do to wile away the quarter hours.
Not to say the competition was at all boring… except when it was. Mme. Gioconda Verkakte-Gemischt has chosen not to dwell on the negative here, for there is truly nothing tackier than picking on young singers in a moment of great nervousness. Reining in, for the moment, our irrepressibly negative nature, we will limit the kvetching to one needlessly picayune comment: for g-d's sake, if you can't sing a trill, don't program a piece with a trill for your debut in front of the world's second most critical crowd. (Has La Scala such a fete? Surely not, for only so much courage can be asked of the young.) And hold off on the Mozart until your sound is squarely more in the realm of Bidu Sayao than that of graduate voice recitals.

Only one young artist could fairly be awarded the "What's She Doing Up There?" award anyway, with its shiny statuette in the shape of Sharon Sweet. Dishing about with the usual suspects at intermission, one got the sense there was pretty much a consensus on who this was. For the most part, everyone onstage had some reason to be there. To Madame's tastes, though, only two sang in a way that said 'get out of my way and hand over the mantel of greatness." That one of these was 21-year-old Lisette Oropesa only goes to show sometimes you just got it, and time will only (we hope) make what is good better. This young chicky could sing us some fine vulnerable Mozart ladies or maybe a
Lakmé or two at the Met or anywhere else, providing vocal loveliness and frightening accuracy for those who lap it up and fodder for the kind of people who love nothing more than to say "her voice isn't big enough for the Met" to grumble at each other all the way home to put on their records of Zinka and cry. Just between you, me, and the ten-foot-tall autographed poster of Ghena Dimitrova on the wall here at Casa Verkakte-Gemischt, Gioconda loves the thrill of a big voice as much as anyone, but some flavors don't come in extra large, and this is one. It's audible, it's beautiful, and nobody's asking her to sing Ortrud. For the record, her pieces here were "Ruhe sanft" and "Una voce poco fa." The former was so appropriately, unobtrusively pretty that nobody got all that rowdy about it. The latter was actually funny, which is something of a feat, and the fiorature were beyond reproach, her pitch better than anyone else in the competition.

The other standout, it seems to us, was self-described-in-bio 'character tenor' Rodell Aure Rosel, who is more or less guaranteed a career. The
Hoffmann aria, arteesteecally speaking, teetered on the brink of pandering, but the voce was all there, so really it seems ignoble to complain. The "Song of the Worm" (from Corigliano's
The Ghosts of Versailles) gets points just for chutzpah in programming and yet more points for having the goods to back it up. This lad (and let me shed a tear here, moved as I am always by the success of fellow Children-of-a-Lesser-Height) knows what his career is going to be about and knows exactly how it's done. Never thought we'd utter this one but: move over, Gerhard Stolze!

Also ridiculously young, bass Jordan Bisch pulled fast one by singing an aria from
Aleko, an opera nobody has ever heard. Ever. The lowest notes ring true, he's bothered to learn good Russian diction (wise move for a bass, eh?) and the climactic note of the piece was held so long the poor fellow was gasping for breath, as were some in the audience. We approve of a singer who isn't afraid to look a little beat up after a good workout. At least it's not the bored look they seem to be teaching in conservatories everywhere.

Well, and everyone seemed to have liked Susan Philips rather a lot. If Gioconda was less than thrilled, it may have more to do with an allergy to Juliette's waltz than anything else. (Not for nothing, we feverishly recall hearing the most poisonous soubrette mince her way through this one during our summer as Decrepit Diva in Residence at The Opera Company that Dare Not Speak Its Name.) Certainly Ms. Philips cannot be faulted in her choice of gowns.
We will not speak here of the dessert portion, wherein several established Met singers fulfilled some itchy clause in their contract by singing a single number while the judges did their basically very easy work. Except to say that Ms. Radvanovsky, about whom this writer has been somewhat agnostic, provided a model to all the youngsters auditioning and wrung tears from the usually stony Gioconda.
Related links: